Choose from any of our reports and we will be happy to send it/them to you via email at no cost.

    Court Criticizes the Insurer for Reading the Policy Incorrectly


    Insurers are not charitable organizations.  They are profit-making companies who will go all the way (and beyond in this case) in enforcing the restrictive covenants of their insurance policies.

    You need to know what your policy says, and negotiate its terms so you have contract certainty.

    In the case in point*, the City of New York was supposed to be protected as “Additional Insured” under the policies of the contractors working on a city facility.  Following injuries on the job, the City went to assert their rights, and they were denied by Zurich Insurance Company, the insurer for one of the subcontractors.

    New York was required to be designated as Additional Insured in the contract between the city and the general contractor.  Zurich insisted the contract had to be direct between the city and the sub.

    The court rejected Zurich’s argument as an “incorrectly cramped reading of the policy language.”

    You were expecting the insurer to give the benefit of the doubt, perhaps?  to go to the other party’s side in an ambiguity?

    Don’t ever count on that.  Make sure your policy (and related contract) language is as it should be in advance.

    *Liberty Mutual Fire Ins. Co. v. Zurich American Ins. Co., No 14 Civ. 7568 (PAC) (S.D.N.Y. Feb 4, 2016)

    Feb 23, 2016

    Licata Risk Licata Risk & Insurance Advisors, Inc.
    265 Franklin Street
    Suite 1702
    Boston, MA 02110
    617-451-2140   advice@licatarisk
    501 East Las Olas Boulevard
    Suite 300/200
    Fort Lauderdale, FL 33301
    LicataRisk Advisors is an independent risk management and insurance consulting firm. We are not brokers and we do not sell insurance. We are not connected to any insurance company or product in any way and do not receive commissions. This is an important difference as you will have an expert on your side who is only committed to you.

    Licata Risk is not a law firm and does not practice law. General advice and contract input by the consultants, including those who are attorneys, is to provide insight into the risk and insurance aspects. Your attorney should be the final authority on any legal matter.